Pizza List of the Fox Cities

Slice, slice, baby!

There’s a lot to love about pizza—from flavorful toppings and perfectly melted cheese to crusts worth savoring. Read on to discover some of the best places to grab a slice in the Fox Cities. Feature photo: Tomaso's Deep Dish Pan Pizza

Tomaso's in Downtown Appleton
New to the Fox Cities in 2025, Tomaso's offers dine‑in and carryout options, making it a convenient choice for a casual meal.

Our pick: The Badger - pizza sauce, pepperoni, cream cheese, and mozzarella.

Via in Appleton by the Fox River Mall (located inside Carmella's Italian Bistro)
Open for lunch and dinner, Via is also new to the Fox Cities in 2025. They serve up Neapolitan-style pizza and offer gluten-free crusts upon request.

Our pick: The Scampi - mozzarella, Gulf shrimp, crispy kale, cherry pepper, and Carmella’s scampi butter

Cranky Pat's in Neenah
Cranky Pat's has served up thin crust pizza for generations, and is a local favorite.

Our pick: Pat's Special: Double helpings of sausage and mushroom, plus two extra toppings of your choice.

Broken Tree Pizza with locations in Appleton and Neenah
This family-owned wood-fired pizza joint uses fresh ingredients to create delicious experiences.

Our pick: Queen Bee - red sauce, Calabrese salami, fresh mozzarella, red pepper flakes, shredded parmesan, green chili oil drizzle - finished with a honey drizzle.

Stuc's Pizza with locations in Appleton and Neenah
Made-to-order pizza with the option for gluten-free crust. Stuc's Pizza also offers specially crafted sandwiches, pastas, and desserts.

Our pick: The Inferno - spicy Italian sausage, jalapenos, classic red sauce, and cheese.

Spectators Sports Bar & Grill in Greenville
Each pizza is made from scratch, and diners can order a specialty 16" pizza or create their own. Featuring a new flavor creation monthly!

Our pick: Philly Cheese - cheesy base, mozzarella, shaved ribeye, onion, green pepper, and mushrooms.

Cannova's Pizzeria & Fine Italian Dining in Downtown Neenah
Cannova's has been a mainstay in Downtown Neenah since 2005. It's a great place for date night or for a nice family dinner.

Our pick: Venetian - olive oil & garlic, mozzarella, basil, ricotta, artichoke heart, diced tomato, and house cheese.

Sammy's Pizza in Neenah
Sammy's Pizza has been baking up delicious hot pizza since 1958. The dough is made daily in the restaurant.

Our pick: House Special - blend of sausage, ground beef, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions, and green peppers.

Butch's Pizza in Kimberly
This pizzeria's story began in 1968 when they sourced Wisconsin-made cheese and fresh, never-frozen meats. Their pizzas are available for dine-in, carry-out, delivery and take & bake.

Our pick: Taco Pizza - taco meat, tomatoes, lettuce, Doritos Chips, black olives.

Pagoni's Pizza in Kaukauna
Pagoni's Pizza is your source for Chicago-style pizza. They also offer thin-crust, stuffed pizza, Sicilian-style pizza, and calzones.

Our pick: The "Don" - Italian beef, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and mozzarella.

Mondo! on the River in Appleton
In the mood for specialty pizza and tasty wine? Mondo! on the River is a wonderful choice that is located along the shores of the Fox River. From pizza, cheese flights, wine flights, beer, and cocktails - there's a lot to love at this wine bar.

Our pick: Cacio e Pancetta - black pepper. parmesan, pancetta and tri-blend cheese.

Stone Arch Brewpub in Appleton
Stone Arch Brewpub has become a household name throughout the Fox Cities and beyond for delicious craft beer. For those with gluten and dairy sensitivity, Stone Arch Brewpub offers a 10-inch gluten-free crust and dairy-free cheese as a premium topping option.

Our pick: Three Meat - bacon, sausage, and pepperoni.

Stone Arch Tied House in Little Chute
Nestled in Little Chute, Stone Arch Tied House offers wonderful pizzas such as Margarita, Chicken Bacon Ranch, and Vegetarian. Their pizza menu also offers some delectable options for those with dairy and gluten sensitivity.

Our pick: Chicken Bacon Ranch - ranch dressing base topped with chicken and bacon.

Hop Yard Ale Works in Appleton
Searching for craft beer and hot pizza? Hop Yard Ale Works has you covered! Additionally, their menu offers vegan cheese and gluten-free crust for those with food sensitivities.

Our pick: The Capone - garlic aioli, provolone, roast beef, hot giardiniera, and au jus.

Cathy Trebatoski

Author

Cathy Trebatoski

Marketing Communications Director

Related Content: